Re: Proposed changes for the…

ERO number

019-4974

Comment ID

59308

Commenting on behalf of

Individual

Comment status

Comment approved More about comment statuses

Comment

Re: Proposed changes for the next edition of Ontario’s Building Code (Winter Consultation)

Background on the CPCI
The Canadian Precast/Prestressed Concrete Institute (CPCI) is the leading source of technical information about precast prestressed concrete, and the Body of Knowledge for precast concrete in Canada. Among other membership categories, we represent the majority of precast prestressed concrete producers, approximately 85% of all precast concrete produced in Canada.

Proposed Changes and Our Concern
First, we would like to thank you for the opportunity to provide feedback on the proposed changes to Ontario Building Code (OBC).

Following a thorough review of the proposed changes for the next edition of OBC, CPCI on behalf of the precast concrete industry is concerned with the changes as presented in clause 3.1.5.6 that they will negatively impact our industry.

Based on our interpretation, this proposed change will perhaps prohibit the use of double wythe insulated precast concrete wall panels for the exterior envelope of sprinklered buildings higher than 6 storeys. Please confirm that this is the correct interpretation of this proposed change. We believe that the AEC community will interpret it this way. We also note that this proposed revision to the OBC contradicts the same clause provisions from the National Building Code of Canada (NBCC).

Background on Typical Precast Concrete Wall Configurations
Precast concrete walls are commonly used as building envelopes on either all precast or hybrid construction buildings, and these elements represent approximately 50% of all precast concrete products produced in Canada. Precast concrete walls can either be insulated panels known as double wythe insulated wall panels (sometimes also referred to as “sandwich” panels), and single wythe panels (often referred to as architectural wall panels or “cladding”).

A typical double wythe insulated wall panel consists of a layer of rigid insulation fully encapsulated in between two layers of concrete (wythes) each with a thickness in a range of 75 mm to 150 mm. The thickness of the insulation layer can vary based on the type and thermal performance needs anywhere between 50 mm to 150 mm, commonly extruded polystyrene (EPS) is used as the insulation layer.

For more detailed information about precast concrete walls please refer to Architectural Precast Concrete Walls: Best Practice guide (2017), https://www.cpci.ca/en/resources/bestpractice_archguide_offer/.

A typical Double Wythe Insulated Precast Concrete Panel Assembly (Architectural Precast Concrete Walls: Best Practice guide, 2017)

Fire Resistance of Precast Wall Panels
Concrete as a material is known to have excellent fire resistance and its fire rating is well established and can be easily defined, see also the excerpt below (CPCI Design Manual 5th Edition). The double wythe insulated precast concrete wall panels are designed accordingly to leverage the excellent fire resistance of concrete on the exposed side, both interior and or exterior while providing continuous and fully encapsulated insulation on the envelope. To enhance further the fire rating of the precast wall assemblies, the panel-to-panel joints are designed accordingly such that the overall assembly meets the desired fire rating. Often ceramic fibre is added to partially fill the joints in addition to the two beads of silicone seal that are typically used in panel-to-panel joints.

Fire endurance of concrete slabs or wall panels (Chapter 6 of CPCI Design Manual 5th Edition, 2017)

Note: the panel thickness is the total concrete thickness from both wythes.

Our Recommendation
Based on the excellent performance to date of double wythe insulated precast concrete wall panels and our understanding that the overall proposed changes are to mainly align the OBC with the NBCC, our ask is to remove the proposed changes to clause 3.5.6 and keep the clause consistent with the requirements of NBCC-15 as follows:

1) Combustible components, other than those permitted by Article 3.1.5.5., are permitted to be used in an exterior wall assembly of a building required to be of noncombustible construction, provided
a) the building is
i) not more than 3 storeys in building height, or
ii) sprinklered throughout, and
b) the wall assembly
i) meets the requirements of Clause 3.1.5.5.(1)(b), or
ii) is protected by masonry or concrete cladding not less than
25 mm thick.

We are hopeful that the Ministry will consider our feedback to address our concern as we strongly believe this proposed change, if implemented, will negatively affect our industry, the AEC community, and the end-user. We are open and would be happy to discuss this further.

Sincerely,

Robert Burak, P.Eng
CPCI President
Val Sylaj, PhD
CPCI Director of Technical Services

val.sylaj@cpci.ca