The Town of Whitby has…

ERO number

019-4974

Comment ID

60148

Commenting on behalf of

The Town of Whitby

Comment status

Comment approved More about comment statuses

Comment

The Town of Whitby has reviewed the Proposed Changes for the Next Edition of Ontario's Building Code (Winter Consultation) and on behalf of Council wishes to provide the following feedback to the Minister of Municipal Affairs and Housing requesting the Province to:

• Ensure the adoption of the tiered National Building Code model immediately results in higher Energy Efficiency Requirements across all building types in comparison to the current OBC.
• Adopt the National Building Code model that includes the tiered standards alongside a timeframe for advancement to higher tiers to ensure a pathway towards net-zero emissions and energy.
• Provide authority to municipalities to require increased performance in energy efficiency through the implementation of tiered and advancing Green Standards.
• Facilitate capacity, education and training in the implementation of the Tiered National Building Code model for municipal planning and building inspection staff, developers, and homebuilders to help build capacity in areas such as airtightness testing, building envelope design and building science.

Importance of a Tiered Approach
The draft National Building Code indicates a tiered approach for energy performance. This would mean that those with authority over the Building Code could choose to require or incentivize builders to meet one or more tiers of the Code. This is an alternate approach to the National Building Code’s current prescriptive requirements. This stepped approach is important as it ensures that new development is advancing and aligning with energy efficiency and greenhouse gas reduction goals over a period of time. A stepped approach also allows municipalities to enforce Green Development Standards through the Building Code Process.

Whitby Green Standard
As of now, the Whitby Green Standard Tier 1 criteria indicates a minimum energy performance of 15% above the 2017 Ontario Building Code regardless of building classification. The Whitby Green Standard was developed to align with the proposed Tiered National Building Code while also aligning with surrounding municipalities that enact Green Development Standards as part of the development process.

The Province has indicated an 18-month transition to the National Building Code, meaning that by the time this comes into effect, Whitby would have advanced to version 2 of the Whitby Green Standard and will be requiring 25% increased energy efficiency above the 2017 Ontario Building Code.

This proposal would put pressure on municipalities to increase the need for minimum energy standards in Green Development Standards while continuing to prevent municipalities in having authority to enforce Green Standards through the Building Code.

Climate Change
Thirty percent of the Region of Durham's total greenhouse gas emissions come from buildings. In 2018, Durham (including Whitby's) households, businesses and other organizations spent $2.5 billion for fuel and electricity. Electricity comprises 36%, and natural gas is 10% of these total costs (Durham Community Energy Plan, 2019).

In order to align with local, Regional, Provincial, and Federal government climate goals, a reduction in greenhouse gas emissions must take place. The proposed Tiered National Building Code offers the opportunity to outline how these greenhouse gas reductions will be achieved.

Whitby has developed a Whitby Green Standard to support the development of complete sustainable communities. Support for Green Development Standards through the Ontario Building Code will help ensure environmental, social and economic innovation. It would facilitate an advancing pathway to net zero new buildings by 2032 and allow for deep energy retrofits to take place between now and 2050 in order to achieve the climate goals for all governmental levels.

The proposed Provincial approach does not align with the Town’s, the Province’s or the Federal Government’s Greenhouse Gas emission reduction targets.

Affordability
Households that spend more than 6% of their after-tax household income on home energy services (or roughly twice the national median) have high home energy cost burdens, and are said to be experiencing energy poverty.
According to the Canadian Urban Sustainability Practitioners Energy Poverty and Equity Explorer, between 15 – 24% of Whitby households spend more than 6% of their household income on heating and electricity costs.
Advancing stronger energy efficient Building Code requirements will ensure a reduction of energy poverty pressures for owners and tenants of both new development and retrofitted buildings. Sustained funding programs should be offered to bridge the gap between standard building methods and green standard building methods for qualifying affordable housing projects.

Studies show that energy-efficient buildings have a quick payback meaning that the increased cost to build or retrofit an energy-efficient home will result in offsetting energy savings over a number of years. It is more cost-effective to build energy efficient homes new than completing deep energy retrofits on existing buildings. However, all buildings need to be upgraded to meet energy and climate pressures and by not advancing energy efficiency standards in the Building Code, this will add future energy and retrofit costs onto taxpayers in the future.

The Town recognizes the housing affordability crisis and by not increasing energy efficiency improvements, one of the root issues of operational affordability for homeowners will not be addressed.