A - OBC & Drain Water Heat…

ERO number

019-4974

Comment ID

60162

Commenting on behalf of

RenewABILITY Energy Inc.

Comment status

Comment approved More about comment statuses

Comment

A - OBC & Drain Water Heat Recovery in Part 9 - Submission 1of3

Brief Background and Updates:
-DWHR energy saving technology has some of these key characteristics:
-proven,
-cost-effective,
-passive (in contrast to HRVs),
-long service life of 50+ years (in contrast to water heaters, furnaces, and windows),
-no defects,
-tamper proof (in contrast to windows and HRVs),
-not readily removed from new homes (in contrast to rental water heaters)
-Over 300,000 DWHR units from over 5 manufacturers have been installed in North America and Europe. In many jurisdictions, DWHR has become ubiquitous in new dwellings.
-There are a number of properly conducted and independent studies which have proven DWHR savings and used to inform energy savings algoritms outside of Cananada, including the AIMC4 project in the United Kingdom. See attached excerpted document “A3 - AIMC4-Briefing-Paper-5_final-pages15&16” two pages with three charts and section called Waste Water Heat Recovery (name for DWHR) in the United Kingdom and with Ontario-manufactured DWHR technology.
-Ontario is the recognized as one of the globally leading jurisdictions for DWHR. Furthermore, in Ontario alone, the DWHR industry employs at least 20 equivalent full-time jobs and the number of green manufacturing jobs is growing as export markets continue to increase.
-Since 2015, the Manitoba Building Code has made DWHR mandatory with a minimum rated efficiency of 42% in all new Part 9 dwellings with reasonable accommodation for exclusions (see enclosed document “A1 - Manitoba Building Code 2021 - 031.11.pdf”).
-Since the 2017 version SB-12, DWHR with a minimum rated efficiency of 42% has been mandatory.
-CSA B55.2 is a well-established Standard that is referenced in Canada and the United States. It was updated in 2020 to allow for other safe materials, thereby increasing innovation and competition.
-CSA B55.1 was updated in 2020 to include performance testing and labelling of “near-horizontal” installed DWHR units. These units should be permitted in this update to satisfy OBC energy saving requirements.
-SB-12 currently only requires that DWHR units be installed for “unequal flow”; this configuration provides a well-established 22.3% lower energy savings versus equal flow with a factor of 0.777 (see attachment file “A2 - ANSIRESNETICC301-2019_vf1.23.19.pdf” for Standard ANSI/RESNET/ICC 301: and refer to section “4.2.2.5.2.11.1. Drain Water Heat Recovery (DWHR) Units”). This update of the OBC should provide for different credits depending upon whether installed for equal and for unequal flow configurations.
-Pressure loss is currently not included in the OBC but is recognized in the Building Codes of many jurisdictions such as: Washington State, IECC 2015, Manitoba, California, and Germany. This update of the OBC should include pressure loss limitations.
-The DWHR industry has a long successful history of training Code Officials, Installers and Designers and is committed to continue this training to address these changes.

 
Proposal Part 1:
“Adopt minimum requirements for Drain Water Heat Recovery (DWHR) as per Manitoba Building Code Part 9.36.4.7 with Revisions, whether or not SB-12 is removed from the OBC in the upcoming update.”

The following are excerpted from the attached Manitoba Building Code (Part 9.36.4.7 and corresponding definitions) with noted recommended revisions when adopting into the OBC:

i) From: 1.4.1.2.(1) Definitions:

Equal flow configuration means, in respect of a drain water heat recovery unit, a configuration that pre-heats both the cold and hot water supplied to the shower or showers from which the drain water heat recovery unit receives drain water.
[unchanged]

Unequal flow configuration means, in respect of a drain water heat recovery unit, a configuration that pre-heats the cold or the hot water supplied to the shower or showers from which the drain water heat recovery unit receives drain water, but not both.
[unchanged]

ii) Include amended Table 1.3.1.2 (difficult to include herein so see attached “A1 - Manitoba Building Code 2021 - 031.11.pdf”) [unchanged]

iii) From: The Manitoba Building Code 9.36.4.7. with Modifications indicated in bold and underlined

9.36.4.7. Drain Water Heat Recovery

1) In buildings of residential occupancy, drain water heat recovery units shall be installed to receive drain water from at least one shower from each dwelling unit in the building.

2) Sentence (1) does not to apply to dwelling units in which:

a) there are no showers; or

b) there are no **stories **beneath any of the showers in the dwelling unit.

3) Drain water heat recovery units shall conform to CSA B55.2, "Drain Water Heat Recovery Units".

4) The vertical and near-horizontal rated efficiencies and pressure loss of a drain water recovery unit shall be determined in conformance with CSA B55.1, "Test Method for Measuring Efficiency and Pressure Loss of Drain Water Heat Recovery Units".

5) The efficiency of a drain water heat recovery unit, when tested in accordance with Sentence (4), shall be not less than 42% where installed in an unequal flow configuration and shall not be less than 33% where installed in an equal flow configuration.

6) The potable water-side pressure loss of a drain water heat recovery unit, when tested in accordance with Sentence (4), shall be not more than

a) 20.7 kPa if it used to supply water to two showers or less in an equal flow configuration, or three showers or less in an unequal flow configuration, and

b) 13.8 kPa if it is used to supply water to more than two showers in an equal flow configuration, or more than three showers in an unequal flow configuration.

7) A single drain water heat recovery unit shall not supply pre-heated water to more than six showers, regardless of whether it supplies the showers in an equal or unequal flow configuration.

8) Drain water heat recovery units shall be installed

a) in an upright position that does not diverge more than 5 from the vertical for vertical rated efficiency,

b) in a near-horizontal position that is 3 to 5 from the horizontal for horizontal rated efficiency,

c) in a position such that the cold water inlet connection is at the drain outlet end of the unit,

d) downstream of a water softener where a water softener is installed, and

e) in a conditioned space or on the warm side of the dewpoint of the wall assembly.

Proposal Part 2:
“In addition to Part 1, include credits in at least 80% of future Prescriptive Paths for DWHR units with higher rated efficiency.”

These additional credits (and all hot water credits should be) would be modelled with a software tool that is compliant to the Standard ANSI/RESNET/ICC 301 because the EnerGuide Rating System does not properly model hot water use, it is not a standard, the new version was not developed with expert consultation/review, and it is not sensitive to home occupancy.

Recommended Efficiency Levels for DWHR Prescriptive Credits
Configuration Minimum Efficiency Prescriptive Credit?
Equal Flow 33% Only if Proposal Part 1 is not Adopted
Equal Flow 42% For Prescriptive Credits
Equal Flow 53% For Prescriptive Credits
Unequal Flow 33% Only if Proposal Part 1 is not Adopted
Unequal Flow 42% For Prescriptive Credits