Commentaire
B - OBC & Drain Water Heat Recovery in Part 3 - Submission 2of3
Brief Background and Updates:
-DWHR energy saving technology has some of these key characteristics:
-proven,
-cost-effective,
-passive (in contrast to HRVs),
-long service life of 50+ years (in contrast to water heaters, furnaces, and windows),
-no defects,
-tamper proof (in contrast to windows and HRVs),
-not readily removed from new homes (in contrast to rental water heaters)
-Over 300,000 DWHR units from over 5 manufacturers have been installed in North America and Europe. In many jurisdictions, DWHR has become ubiquitous in new dwellings.
-About 10,000 DWHR units are savings energy in commercial and multi-family residential buildings in North America and Europe every day, most of which serve sets of apartment washrooms.
-The US Department of Energy has studied and recognized DWHR to be an effective energy saving class of technology since as early as 2000. For example, the attached report: “B3 - ORNL Report Duluth-Triplex.pdf”
-The following attached course with file name: “B4 - 2202 - Drain Water Heat Recovery Technologies, Research, Case Studies, and Recent Sample Projects.pdf” has been given to thousands of Engineers and Architects across North America
-Ontario is the recognized as one of the globally leading jurisdictions for DWHR. Furthermore, in Ontario alone, the DWHR industry employs at least 20 equivalent full-time jobs and the number of green manufacturing jobs is growing as export markets continue to increase.
-Since the 2017 version SB-12, DWHR with a minimum rated efficiency of 42% has been mandatory. Since 2015, the Manitoba Building Code has made DWHR mandatory in all new Part 9 dwellings with reasonable accommodation for.
-CSA B55.2 is a well-established Standard that is referenced in Canada and the United States. It was updated in 2020 to allow for other safe materials, thereby increasing innovation and competition.
-CSA B55.1 was updated in 2020 to include performance testing and labelling of “near-horizontal” installed DWHR units. These units should be permitted in this update to satisfy OBC energy saving requirements.
-SB-10 does not have energy credits for DWHR
-The International Energy and Conservation Code (IECC) 2015 and newer has a simple energy credit calculation methodology for Multi-Family residential buildings (equivalent to Part 3 of OBC). See attached excerpted TABLE C407.5.1(1) from IECC 2015: “B1 - Table from IECC 2015”
-The simple IECC 2015 energy credits are only for unequal flow configurations
-The IECC 2015 also has pressure loss limitation clauses in order to avoid flow problems in buildings.
-Energy Credits for multi-family residential were available in Canada within the Commercial Building Incentive Program (CBIP) starting in 2004 as per the attached excerpted Appendix F: “B2 - CBIP DWHR 2004-12” then were transferred to the former MNECB.
-A NECB code change submission was made in 2013 but there was never any feedback or opportunity to discuss the submission.
-Pressure loss is currently not included in the OBC but is recognized in the Building Codes of many jurisdictions such as: Washington State, IECC 2015, Manitoba, California, and Germany. This update of the OBC should include pressure loss limitations.
-The DWHR industry has a long successful history of training Code Officials, Installers and Designers and is committed to continue this training to address these changes.
Proposal
For the OBC Part 3 to include IECC 2015 Energy Credits but also allow for equal flow configuration credits. In light of the NECB it is not clear where exactly these clauses ought to be placed. The following is the key portion of TABLE C407.5.1(1) from IECC 2015 with prosed modifications marked in bold and underlined:
i) DWHR Energy Credits
SWHF = Service water heat recovery factor
For Group R, “as proposed” multiplied by SWHF.
For other than Group R, as proposed multiplied by efficiency as provided by the manufacturer of the DWHR unit.
e. The SWHF shall be applied as follows:
1. Where potable water from the DWHR unit supplies not less than one shower and not greater than two showers in the unequal flow configuration, of which the drain water from the same showers flows through the DWHR unit then SWHF = [1 – (DWHR unit efficiency · 0.36)].
2. Where potable water from the DWHR unit supplies not less than three showers and not greater than four showers in the unequal flow configuration, of which the drain water from the same showers flows through the DWHR unit then SWHF = [1 – (DWHR unit efficiency · 0.33)].
3. Where potable water from the DWHR unit supplies not less than five showers and not greater than six showers in the unequal flow configuration, of which the drain water from the same showers flows through the DWHR unit, then SWHF = [1 – (DWHR unit efficiency · 0.26)].
4. Where potable water from the DWHR unit supplies not less than one shower and not greater than two showers in the equal flow configuration, of which the drain water from the same showers flows through the DWHR unit then SWHF = [1 – (DWHR unit efficiency · 0.46)].
5. Where potable water from the DWHR unit supplies not less than three showers and not greater than four showers in the equal flow configuration, of which the drain water from the same showers flows through the DWHR unit then SWHF = [1 – (DWHR unit efficiency · 0.42)].
6. Where potable water from the DWHR unit supplies not less than five showers and not greater than six showers in the equal flow configuration, of which the drain water from the same showers flows through the DWHR unit, then SWHF = [1 – (DWHR unit efficiency · 0.33)].
7. Where Items 1 through 3 are not met, SWHF = 1.0.
ii) Pressure Loss for Multi-Family Residential
R403.5.4 Drain water heat recovery units. Drain water heat recovery units shall comply with CSA B55.2. Drain water heat recovery units shall be tested in accordance with CSA B55.1. Potable water-side pressure loss of drain water heat recovery units shall be less than 3 psi (20.7 kPa) for individual units connected to one or two showers. Potable water-side pressure loss of drain water heat recovery units shall be less than 2 psi (13.8 kPa) for individual units connected to three or more showers.
iii) Pressure Loss for Commercial
C404.8 Drain water heat recovery units. Drain water heat recovery units shall comply with CSA B55.2. Potable waterside pressure loss shall be less than 10 psi (69 kPa) at maxi- mum design flow. For Group R occupancies, the efficiency of drain water heat recovery unit efficiency shall be in accordance with CSA B55.1.
Documents justificatifs
Liens connexes
Soumis le 13 mars 2022 11:53 PM
Commentaire sur
Modifications proposées pour la prochaine édition du Code du bâtiment de l’Ontario (consultation hivernale)
Numéro du REO
019-4974
Identifiant (ID) du commentaire
60170
Commentaire fait au nom
Statut du commentaire